Wabi-Sabi: Embracing the Beauty of Imperfection, Transience, and the Art of Living Mindfully
![]() |
Wabi-Sabi: Embracing the Beauty of Imperfection & Transience |
Introduction: The Beauty of Imperfection and Transience
By a gentle
investigation of Wabi-Sabi, we'll discover how it can change the way we live,
allowing us to appreciate the beauty in the mundane and the everyday, instead
of constantly pursuing an elusive state of perfection. From the humble objects
in our homes, the wrinkles on our faces, to the changing seasons, Wabi-Sabi
encourages us to savor the transient beauty in all things.
In addition, we
will see how poetry—particularly poems by John Keats—reflects the same
impermanence and beauty of Wabi-Sabi, while revealing greater insight into the
human condition. Keats' Negative Capability philosophy—the capacity to exist
with uncertainty and mystery—is analogous to Wabi-Sabi's embracing of the
imperfections and impermanence of life. His poems, Ode to Autumn and Ode on a
Grecian Urn, reflect the very essence of beauty in what is incomplete,
transitory, and fleeting.
Secondly, we will
examine in which ways Islamic worldview also aligns with them, especially what
it says on the transiency of the world and everlastingness of hereafter. Quran
has deep commentary on how life should be experienced keeping in view its transitoriness,
wherein it inspires people to be satisfied and peaceful about present, being
well aware of the fact that all things pass away.
Finally, we shall
see how these age-old philosophies can be translated into our current lives
today, especially through the eyes of Beth Kempton's book Wabi-Sabi: Find
Beauty in Imperfection, which provides useful tips on how to adopt these
principles in contemporary living.
By examining
Wabi-Sabi, Keats' Negative Capability, and the Islamic concept of transience,
this blog will illustrate how accepting imperfection and transience not only
provides a richer sense of meaning but can also result in a more mindful,
peaceful, and contented life. Rather than pursuing an impossible ideal of
flawlessness, we are encouraged to appreciate the imperfect, the transitory,
and the incomplete—for it is in these that the real beauty of life lies.
Outline of the content in this blog is:
Introduction: The Beauty of Imperfection and Transience
What is Wabi-Sabi?
Principles of Wabi-Sabi:
The Influence of Wabi-Sabi on Modern Life
Poetry and Wabi-Sabi Philosophy of Japan
The Book "Wabi-Sabi" by Beth Kempton: A Deep Dive into
Imperfection and Transience
Impact on Modern Life
John Keats' Negative Capability: Embracing Uncertainty
Islamic Concepts of Transience and the Afterlife
Accepting the Impermanence of Life
Accepting Beauty in Imperfection and Finiteness
Practical Advice on Practicing Wabi-Sabi in Everyday Life
Conclusion
This blog contains affiliate links from Amazon.
Books on Wabi Sabi
Shop Wabi Sabi Furniture
References
What is Wabi-Sabi?
Deep within lies
the Japanese aesthetic Wabi-Sabi, which venerates the organic cycle of growth,
decay, and imperfection. It values the ephemeral nature of things, finding
beauty in what is incomplete, unfinished, or worn. Contrary to Western
conceptions of perfection—where order, flawlessness, and symmetry are found
beautiful—Wabi-Sabi finds depth in what is worn, irregular, and imperfect. It
essentially encourages us to rediscover the world in a more mindful, humble,
and true manner.
Wabi-Sabi has its
roots firmly based in Zen Buddhism, where mindfulness, acceptance, and the
realization that nothing lasts in this life are central to its philosophy. By
accepting transience, we can achieve peace of mind in the moment, instead of
spending it constantly reaching for some future ideal or dwelling on past
failures.
![]() |
Finding Perfection in Imperfection |
Principles of Wabi-Sabi:
Imperfection:
Wabi-Sabi is the philosophy that there is beauty in things that are imperfect, rough, or uneven. A cracked pottery bowl or a worn wooden beam speaks of time, life, and experience. The imperfections add character and depth to objects, and they become more precious.
![]() |
The Beauty of Imperfect Things |
Transience:
Wabi-Sabi
appreciates the fleeting nature of time. All things are transient, and it is
this transient quality of life that makes every moment valuable. The yellowing
of a leaf, the corrosion of metal, or the aging of a painting all indicate the
natural course of life and the inexorable march towards deterioration. It is in
this transience that we see beauty.
Simplicity:
Wabi-Sabi
encourages going back to simplicity. The beauty of life does not reside in
abundance or in intricate patterns, but in the plain, the muted, and the
humble. Through simplicity, we are taught to appreciate what really
matters—peace, lucidity, and sincerity.
Asymmetry:
Acceptance of asymmetry is yet another
integral aspect of Wabi-Sabi. Contrary to Western principles of flawless
symmetry and tidiness, Japanese beauty appreciates the naturally uneven aspects
of things as a reflection of life's spontaneous nature, which cannot be
organized along strictly symmetrical lines.
The Influence of Wabi-Sabi on Modern Life
In the world we
live in, Wabi-Sabi teaches us to release the pressure to be perfect at all
times. Most of us exert ourselves to become something idealized—either in the
way we look, in our accomplishments, or in things that we own—but all these
efforts cause us dissatisfaction and stress. Wabi-Sabi calls us to turn our
attention to the inside, where we can be at peace with accepting things instead
of striving for impossible ideals.
By integrating
Wabi-Sabi into your life, you can gain the ability to value the imperfections
of your environment and your own life experiences. It teaches mindfulness and
helps you to value moments that otherwise would pass unnoticed—be it the cracks
in the road, the dings in your phone, or the wrinkles on your face.
Poetry and Wabi-Sabi Philosophy of Japan
Poetry is the
perfect vehicle by which the essence of Wabi-Sabi is conveyed, seeing the
beauty in perfection, imperfection, and nature. Classic haiku poetry of Japan,
with its minimalist expression and emphasis on nature, tends to reflect the
philosophy of Wabi-Sabi. In haiku, the ephemeral nature of life and beauty is
expressed by close observation of the world.
For instance, the
celebrated haiku master Matsuo Bashō frequently called to mind Wabi-Sabi by
emphasizing nature's impermanence. Perhaps one of his best-known haikus goes as
follows:
An old silent pond.
A frog jumps into the pond—
Splash! Silence again.
This haiku captures
the impermanence of life, framing a moment in time—the splashing frog—before it
disappears, slipping into silence. It's the ultimate example of Wabi-Sabi:
containing the essence of a mundane, ephemeral instant that is transient and unpredictable.
Through reading and
writing poetry with the Wabi-Sabi perspective, we realize that beauty is not
only in what is spotless or flawless but in the subtle, transient moments that
go unnoticed.
The Book "Wabi-Sabi" by Beth Kempton: A
Deep Dive into Imperfection and Transience
In her book
Wabi-Sabi: Find Beauty in Imperfection (2018), Beth Kempton presents a modern
take on the Japanese philosophy of Wabi-Sabi. Kempton explores in depth how
this ancient idea can be used in everyday life today, inviting readers to
accept the imperfections, transience, and simplicity that are at the heart of
the philosophy.
The book is a
primer for learning Wabi-Sabi not only as an aesthetic, but as a life mindset
and embracing the beauty of the mundane and fleeting moments and objects that
may otherwise be overlooked. In a world where perfection is coveted, Kempton's
book shows how imperfection and passing are not to be avoided, but to be
embraced.
Themes Explored in the Book
Embracing Imperfection:
One of the central themes of Wabi-Sabi is accepting and appreciating imperfection. Kempton uses personal stories, cultural history, and insightful reflections to guide readers into the practice of noticing the beauty in cracks, flaws, and the unusual. Wabi-Sabi teaches that there is inherent beauty in what is imperfect, whether it's the handcrafted items around us, the scars that tell our stories, or the natural world that is always in a state of flux.
![]() |
Flaws Make it Perfect |
The Aesthetics of Impermanence:
Kempton relates
Wabi-Sabi to the idea of impermanence, pointing out how everything is
transitory. From the weathered look of a beloved object, the changing seasons,
to the fleeting moments in life, she discusses how these transitory aspects are
what give life its meaning and richness. This search is especially poignant at
a moment when a great many are concerned with attaining permanence or stability
in a universe that is anything but permanent.
Simplicity and Slowness
The second
important element of Wabi-Sabi that Kempton refers to is the value of
simplicity. In our society of consumerism, where we are all so busy seeking
excess, Wabi-Sabi calls us to pause and to revel in the simplicity of beauty.
By keeping things simple and honouring what is really important, be it an
object, a moment, or a relationship, we can find space in our lives to enjoy
real contentment and peace.
Healing and Acceptance
Kempton points out
that the practice of Wabi-Sabi can also be a healing process, especially for
individuals who are experiencing trauma, loss, or emotional hurt. By accepting
the fact that everything changes, we can have peace in the act of letting go. Just
like a broken pottery bowl can be repaired with gold in the art of Kintsugi, so
can we discover strength and beauty in our emotional wounds.
Wabi-Sabi in Practice
The book is not
only at the philosophical level. It provides practical tips and exercises that
can be applied to everyday life. Some of these are:
Attentive Observation:
Inviting the reader
to be slow and watch the little things in life—the texture of objects, patterns
of nature, or the imperfections that create our individuality. This discipline
calls us to see the beauty of the ordinary and appreciate the small things that
shape our existence.
Decluttering and Simplifying
Capitalizing on
Wabi-Sabi's affection for simplicity, Kempton urges readers to sweep away the
physical and mental detritus that so often burdens us. By doing so, we make
space for peace, clarity, and a richer sense of what's truly important.
Creating Sacred Spaces
The second
suggestion of the book is the concept of designing spaces at home or the office
that are not only visually appealing, but emotionally rich. A
Wabi-Sabi-inspired space welcomes the imperfect, the worn, and the natural and
aims to create an environment that encourages mindfulness, calmness, and
authenticity.
Impact on Modern Life
Beth Kempton's Wabi-Sabi provides a rich antidote to the stress and unhappiness that can result from a relentless pursuit of perfection. Her observations are a welcome counterpoint to the perfectionism culture that pervades social media, advertising, and contemporary life as a whole. By accepting the natural imperfections and transience of beauty in our lives, we can cultivate greater gratitude, mindfulness, and happiness.
![]() |
Cherish the Fleeting Moments |
The book challenges us to re-evaluate our relationship with things and even our own self. Rather than trying to achieve the perfect life, Kempton suggests that we accept and appreciate our built-in flaws, our impermanence, and our relationships with other people.
A Mindful Approach to Life
In Wabi-Sabi: Find
Beauty in Imperfection, Beth Kempton provides a gorgeous and accessible
introduction to embracing the classic Japanese philosophy of Wabi-Sabi in
everyday life. In her uncovering of imperfection, transience, and simplicity,
she offers a path to living more consciously, authentically, and in balance
with the natural rhythm of life. In a world that tends to encourage us towards
perfection, Kempton's book reminds us that beauty and serenity are sometimes
found in the imperfection and the acceptance of the natural order of life.
Whether you seek to make your home more serene, contemplate the transience of your own life, or merely see the beauty in the ordinary moments, Wabi-Sabi provides a visionary lens through which to see the world and ourselves.
![]() |
Find Serenity Amidst Chaos |
John Keats' Negative Capability: Embracing
Uncertainty
English poet John
Keats presented a philosophy that is relevant to Wabi-Sabi: Negative
Capability. Keats explained Negative Capability as the capacity to live with
doubt, mystery, and uncertainty without the necessity for explanations or
solutions immediately. To Keats, a great poet or artist must be capable of
living with ambiguity, and while doing so, producing art forms that capture the
beauty of imperfection and uncertainty in life.
In the context of Wabi-Sabi, Negative Capability is also in perfect harmony with the acceptance of life's inherent flaws and uncertainty. Just as Wabi-Sabi accepts the beauty of the imperfect and the ephemeral, Keats' philosophy accepts the beauty of the unknown, the ephemeral, and the impermanent aspects of life. Both philosophies require a change of heart—away from the need to control and perfect and towards the acceptance of life as it is.
Keats' style of
art—and living—reminds us that beauty lies in the unknown and the disorder. By
embracing the enigma of life, we can discover greater significance in the
unexpected and the unfinished. Keats' poems, like Ode to Autumn and Ode on a
Grecian Urn, eloquently demonstrate this principle.
Ode to Autumn
In Ode to Autumn,
Keats examines the fleeting nature of life in the same way that Wabi-Sabi does,
by looking at the change in seasons. He does not mourn the waning of autumn but
rather rejoices in it, finding the beauty in the natural process of breakdown
and regeneration.
![]() |
The soft-dying day … vines in autumn. Photograph: Alamy |
"Season of mists and mellow fruitfulness,
Close bosom-friend of the maturing sun;
Conspiring with him how to load and bless
With fruit the vines that round the thatch-eves run."
In this, Keats
anthropomorphizes autumn, freezing the instant of change and transience. He
enjoys autumn's plenty but also realizes that autumn will finally disappear
into winter. The poem sums up the philosophy of acceptance—that beauty is not
only to be found in the instant of perfection but in the process of decay and
transience as well.
Ode on a Grecian Urn
![]() |
Metropolitan Museum of Art |
In Ode on a Grecian Urn, Keats analyses how
art relates to time. The urn is petrified in time, and it shows a moment of
perpetuity beauty, but Keats points out its paradox—the individuals on the urn
are in a condition of imperfection and doubt, stuck eternally in time.
"Thou still unravish'd bride of quietness,
Thou foster-child of Silence and slow Time,
Sylvan historian, who canst thus express
A flowery narrative more sweetly than our rhyme.
The urn's images
portray the beauty of the eternal, but Keats also sees the conflict between the
immortality of the art and the transience of life. The urn itself is ideally
flawed, both in its representation of the transience of life and the longevity
of art. It addresses the human condition—the perpetual beauty of the
transitory.
Islamic Concepts of Transience and the Afterlife
In Islam, the
concept of transience is a recurring theme that is deeply embedded in the
teachings of the Qur'an. The Qur'an reminds believers that everything in this
life is temporary. The material world is fleeting, and ultimately, all things will pass. The idea of
Zuhur (transience) encourages us to live mindfully, knowing that our time in
this world is limited.
The Islamic belief in the afterlife is an important aspect
that emphasizes the ephemeral nature of life. Muslims are convinced that the
real aim of existence is to attain closeness to Allah (God) and to be prepared
for the life after death, which is eternal. The transience of life is therefore
not perceived as something to be dreaded, but as a call to live righteous
lives and in harmony with the divine instructions.
The Qur'an mentions in Surah
Al-Hadid (57:20):
Know that the life of this world is but play and amusement, and pomp and mutual boasting, and multiplying wealth and children: like the rain whose plants grow, to delight the disbelievers, but then it withers and you will see it turning yellow, and in the end, it becomes chaff.
This verse elegantly summarizes the fleeting nature of existence, equating the loveliness of the world's wonders with their final disintegration. Islamic teachings, just like Wabi-Sabi, also guide us to celebrate the beauty in the fleeting aspect of life and dwell on that which is forever—the life beyond death.
Accepting the Impermanence of Life
Wabi-Sabi, John
Keats' Negative Capability philosophy, and Islamic philosophy of transience all
have one thing in common: they preach the impermanence of life. All these
philosophies encourage us to look for beauty not in perfection but in the
natural process of withering away, the blemishes, and the unknowns of life.
Accepting them, we can live a more conscious, tranquil, and more satisfying
life.
In a universe that
sometimes Favors too much materialism and seeking idealized perfection, it's
necessary to stand back and see the beauty found in imperfection and the
temporary nature of our lives. From the eyes of Wabi-Sabi, consideration of
Keats' philosophy, or the religion of Islam, we are cautioned to embrace the
moment, find peace in uncertainty, and observe the fleeting loveliness about
us.
By releasing the
need to control and accepting the incomplete, we can develop a deeper sense of
connection with ourselves, the world, and the divine.
Accepting Beauty in Imperfection and
Finiteness
In a globally
fixated culture increasingly obsessed with perfection, control, and striving
for an idealized life, the Japanese philosophy of Wabi-Sabi provides a healthy
antidote. In its embrace of imperfection, transience, and simplicity, Wabi-Sabi
invites us to find beauty not in the flawless, but in the natural imperfections
and inevitable change that characterize our own lives. This philosophy engages
us in rediscovering the real, the imperfect, and the transitory—qualities that
are in danger of being lost in our hyper-speed, perfection-obsessed culture.
With Wabi-Sabi, we
come to understand that imperfection is not something to be shunned, but
something to be cherished. It teaches us to value the distinguishing textures,
the gentle cracks, and the evanescent moments that give life its richness and
depth. Whether it is a handmade item, the wrinkles on the face of a loved one,
or the changing of the seasons in nature, Wabi-Sabi reminds us to see beauty in
the everyday, the transitory, and the uncompleted.
The alignment of
Wabi-Sabi and John Keats' Negative Capability philosophy further strengthens
our appreciation of accepting the unknown and the imperfect. Keats' invitation
to live in the midst of uncertainty is a parallel to the Wabi-Sabi acceptance
of life's impermanence. In his own poetry, like Ode to Autumn and Ode on a
Grecian Urn, Keats depicts beauty in the passing and the unfinished, just as
Wabi-Sabi sees deep beauty in the cracks and the imperfections of the world.
Additionally, the
Islamic perception of transience also perfectly complements Wabi-Sabi's
perspective. The Qur'an brings us to the forethought of the transiency of this
life, calling on the believers to think only of the eternal and live in
awareness. This is precisely in line with Wabi-Sabi's call to accept the
transience of life as it comes, to seek peace in the fact that nothing lasts
for all times.
Beth Kempton's book Wabi-Sabi: Find Beauty in Imperfection provides a straightforward, down-to-earth guide to incorporating the spirit of this philosophy into our own lives today. Through mindfulness, acceptance, and seeking simplicity, Kempton illustrates how Wabi-Sabi can be used as a counterpoint to the stifling demands of perfectionism. The book asks us to build sacred space in our own homes, clear minds, and love the small, imperfect things that make our lives unique. It is a gentle reminder that, instead of striving for perfection, we can learn to enjoy and live at peace with the beauty of impermanence.
Practical Advice on Practicing Wabi-Sabi in Everyday Life
Bringing Wabi-Sabi to your everyday life is all about appreciating imperfection, impermanence, and simplicity. Here are some practical advice on how to cultivate this mindful way of living:
1. Honor Imperfection in Your Environment:
Cherish worn and weathered objects, such as a chipped teacup or faded rug, that tell stories and have character. Design sacred spaces that speak of your true self, loving the beauty of imperfection.
2. Slow Down and Be Present:
Take time to notice the little things around you—the shifting light, the textures, and the ephemeral beauty in daily life. Practice thankfulness for these little moments and enjoy them as they are.
![]() |
Slow Down, Appreciate Impermanence |
3. Simplify Your Life:
Declutter both your physical and mental space. Remove unnecessary items and commitments, creating room for what truly matters. This aligns with Wabi-Sabi’s focus on simplicity and being present in the moment.
![]() |
Embrace Imperfection at Home |
4. Connect with Nature:
Spend time outdoors and appreciate the natural world’s imperfections—the changing seasons, weathered trees, and the cracks in the earth. Nature embodies Wabi-Sabi’s celebration of ephemeral beauty.
5. Practice Acceptance:
Release perfectionism and accept the impermanence of things. Whether it is your house, relationships, or your own self, learn to accept the unfinished, the broken, and the imperfect aspects of yourself.
6. Enjoy Handmade and Imperfect Things:
Find handcrafted or imperfect things which have a history behind them. Whether a handmade cup or a mended object, these things retain the spirit of Wabi-Sabi—truthfulness and personality.
7. Celebrate Time's Passage:
Rejoice in the transient nature of life by embracing changes around you. Celebrate milestones and relish in the seasons, finding beauty in every moment of life.
Including these practices, you are able to implement the Wabi-Sabi philosophy into your daily life, allowing for peace and understanding of life's imperfections. It is about accepting the beauty in the temporary and finding richness in the unfinished.
Conclusion
In the end, then, the principles of Wabi-Sabi lead us to accept and be more thankful. Rather than striving ever more desperately towards an impossible perfection, we are challenged to cultivate peace in the moment—to enjoy the beauty in what is not perfect, evanescent, and incomplete. Through embracing such a vision, we are encouraged to recall that true peace and contentment exist not in perfection, but in the subtle, transitory moments that constitute our passage through life.
Adding the philosophy of Wabi-Sabi to our everyday lives would make us develop a stronger connection with the world, with people, and with ourselves. It would teach us to derive significance from the imperfect and to Savor the temporary nature of life—where, in the end, beauty is not located in the perfect but in the imperfect, in the unexpected, and in the act of living itself.
Read Books on Wabi Sabi
Wabi Sabi - The Art of Finding the Beauty of Imperfection: Discover
Timeless Japanese Wisdom to Cultivate Peace, Joy, and Balance in a Perfectly
Imperfect Life | Includes Daily Exercises and Practices Paperback – July 10,
2024 by Makoto Saito (Author) Amazon
Koren, Leonard. Wabi-Sabi for Artists, Designers, Poets &
Philosophers. Imperfect Publishing, 2008. Amazon
Wabi Sabi: The Japanese Art of Impermanence - Understanding the Zen
Philosophy of Beauty in Simplicity Paperback – Illustrated, November 15, 2003, by
Andrew Juniper (Author), Amazon
Wabi Sabi The Art of Imperfection: Discover the traditional Japanese
Aesthetics and Learn How to Enjoy the Beauty of Imperfection and Live a
Wabi-Sabi Lifestyle Paperback – March 25, 2020 by Osami Nishimura (Author), Amazon
The Book of Tea Hardcover – Illustrated, June 20, 2011 by Okakura Kakuzo
(Author), Amazon
The Message of the Qur'an
Hardcover – April 1, 2005 by Muhammad Asad (Author), Amazon
The Qur'an (Oxford World's Classics) by M. A. S. Abdel Haleem Amazon
In the Footsteps of the Prophet: Lessons from the Life of Muhammad
Hardcover – February 5, 2007 by Tariq Ramadan (Author), Amazon
Shop Wabi Sabi Furniture
11.8 Inch White Wabi Sabi Pendant Light Fixture for Kitchen Island
Dining Room Over Sink Bar Modern Hanging Lighting, Concrete Finish, Amazon
BOMINICA Irregular Wall Mirror Asymmetrical Mirror Frameless Mirror for
Bathroom Living Room Entryway Bedroom, 19.5" x 33.5", Amazon
N&V Folding Mattress Sofa Bean Bag Bed, Foam Filling Folding Mattress
Sofa, Includes Removable and Machine Washable Cover, Soft Premium Faux Fur
(Medium, White), Amazon
HOMECOOKIN Asymmetrical Mirror Wood, 19.5" x 30.5" Irregular
Wall Mirror Wood Framed Mirror Decor for Bathroom Living Room Bedroom Entryway,
Amazon
SAFAVIEH Natural Fiber Collection Area Rug - 6' x 9', Grey &
Natural, Handmade Chunky Textured Jute 0.75-inch Thick, Ideal for High Traffic
Areas in Living Room, Bedroom (NF447K), Amazon
50cm Modern Pendant Light for Dining Room Kitchen Island Hallway
Restaurant Hanging Lamp E26 Base Japanese Wabi-Sabi Style Bird Nest Shape
Lighting Fixture (Matte White, B Shape, 50cm/19.7inch), Amazon
POLY & BARK Napa Leather Couch – Right-Facing Sectional Leather Sofa
- Tufted Back Full Grain Leather Couch with Feather-Down Topper on Seating
Surfaces – Pure-Aniline Italian Leather – Cognac Tan, Amazon
POLY & BARK Napa
88.5” Sofa in Full-Grain Semi-Aniline Italian Tanned Leather, Onyx Black, Amazon
References
Kempton, Beth. Wabi-Sabi: Find Beauty in Imperfection.
TarcherPerigee, 2018.
Powell, Richard. The Japanese Aesthetic: Wabi-Sabi. New York:
Oxford University Press, 2011.
Keats, John. The Complete Poems. Edited by John Barnard, Penguin
Classics, 2014.
Motion, Andrew. Keats. St. Martin's Press, 1997.
Waiting and Wanting in John Keats’s ‘Ode on a Grecian Urn’, By Gabriela Riccardi , https://www.theatlantic.com/culture/archive/2017/04/favorite-poems-john-keats-ode-on-a-grecian-urn/622491/
Bradley, A.C. Keats. Macmillan and Co., 1905.,
Haleem, M.A.S. The Qur'an. Oxford University Press, 2004.
Asad, Muhammad. The Message of the Qur'an. Dar al-Andalus, 1980.
A CRITICAL STUDY OF MUHAMMAD ASAD'S THE MESSAGE OF THE QURAN (1980) https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/144513777.pdf
Ramadan, Tariq. In the Footsteps of the Prophet: Lessons from the Life of Muhammad. Oxford University Press, 2007.
Comments
Post a Comment